Historical Reference

On Journeys Between Herat, and Khiva by Goldsmid

Journal of the Royal United Service Institution
VOL. XIX. 1875. No. LXXX.

LECTURE.

Page 1Page 2 - Page 3 - Page 4Page 5Page 6Page 7Page 8Page 9 - Page 10Page 11Page 12 Page 13Page 14Page 15Page 16Page 17Page 18Page 19Page 20Page 21

Page 3

 beyond the limits of the Hindu Kush, to find themselves on Russian soil. It is not our business in this place to inquire into the advantages or disadvantages of a state of things not by any means abnormal, nor contrary to the precedents of Time and natural development. We have to congratulate ourselves on at least one mission during the past year, which has broken ground in a most interesting quarter, and brought home information on the political and physical geography of Eastern Turkistan and the Pamir Steppe or valleys, as well as other scientific results of well-conducted research. And if we have no recent similar missions to credit to England over the regions lying between the Tian-Shan mountains and the Caspian, we may find consolation in the fact that a British Officer has been permitted to accompany the Russian Expedition, which in the past summer commenced exploring the mouths of the Oxus with a view of perfecting as much as possible the water communication so essential to the security of Russian interests in Turkistan. Major Herbert Wood is working under different conditions from those which influenced his eminent namesake, Lieutenant John Wood of the Indian Navy; but there is no reason why good utilitarian service should not be rendered at the outlet as at the source of the ancient river.

Missions of Abbott and Shakespeare, 1840. — Before entering upon the practical business of the present paper, I will say a few words on the Officers whose routes we are about to retrace. Missions to Persia and the neighboring tracts are not sufficiently popular to be well known and understood in England on their merits alone. They require the newspaper paragraph, the publisher's advertisement, and last not least the temper and character of the times to support them; for without such significant aid they are weighed and judged within the official world which is their birth place; and beyond the circle of that world they have no real existence. In the case referred to, the publisher has not been wanting, but interest in the theme treated, has flickered and failed, and its revival has been at an hour when later journeys and incidents are in demand. If I endeavor to deal with the matter briefly, it is simply because my explanation must be of the nature of a preface.

Major-General James Allott, C.B. — Captain James Abbott of the Bengal Artillery was at Herat in 1839, when Major D'Arcy Todd, of the same corps, had entered upon the duties of Envoy at that important place, in the face of difficulties compared to which the settlement of an Alabama question would be clover and child's play. Among other proceedings due to the circumstances of the day, the latter Officer managed to open communications with the Khan of Khiva, who responded to the friendly messages of the British by dispatching an Ambassador from himself to the Indian Government. As might have been anticipated, the demands of the Khariznrians were more than could be complied with; but in place of a disappointing letter, Captain Abbott was deputed to visit their capital in person. At Khiva there was considerable commotion, for it was the period when

JBOC Notes:  The missions of Abbott and Shakespeare were in the same time frame as the attempt of the British to seize and hold Afghanistan. This resulted in the First Afghan War 1840 - 1842. The war was a disaster for the British. They ruled through their puppet Shah Shuja but that rule extended no further than the town walls that they garrisoned and even then not completely. In 1842 the Afghans rose up and slaughtered nearly to a man the Army of the Indus. Had Englandbeen able to hold Afghanistan then Khiva and Bukhara might have fallen to the British rather than the Russians. The parallels between the First Afghan War and the current American occupation of Afghanistan are chilling. 

Page 1Page 2 - Page 3 - Page 4Page 5Page 6Page 7Page 8Page 9 - Page 10Page 11Page 12 Page 13Page 14Page 15Page 16Page 17Page 18Page 19Page 20Page 21

Barry O'Connell's Notes Main Index